SYC Summer Series 2023/24
Protest information as at 2024-05-03 09:44:32

Print This Page

No PROTESTOR PROTESTEE Race HEARING Arb'n FACTS AND CONCLUSIONS OUTCOME RULE
4 Summer Wind
SM580
TT / B
Bruschetta VI
AUS5400
B
12 1954 on
21/12/2023
    AUS5400 Accepted Post Race Penalty 13
3 MAGIC
SM616
3
FUN AND GAMES
SM600
3
  1100 on
16/12/2023
  FACTS
1.Approaching the weather mark to round to starboard, with SM616 on starboard tack and SM600 on port tack on a converging course.
2.SM600 luffed, passed head to wind in an effort to tack to starboard.
3.SM600 stalled while tacking and slowed.
4.SM616 was initially unaware of SM600s position and when they did see her, SM616 altered course to windward in an attempt to avoid contact.
5.The bow of SM616 made contact with the starboard stern of SM600.
6.Both boats retired from the race.
7.There were no injuries.

CONCLUSIONS
1.The damage to SM600 was considered serious.
2.SM600 broke RRS13 and 14
3.SM616 by not keeping a lookout failed to do everything reasonably possible to avoid contact and broke RRS14 (Case 107)
As both boats retired from the race, no further penalty is be applied. 13,14, 61.1(a)(4)